AITA for Telling My Kids, ‘Mom Said No’: A Dad’s Dilemma

Introduction: The Tale of Two Tiny Tyrants

Listen up, folks, because today we’re diving into the treacherous waters of parenting dynamics. Grab your life jackets and settle in, because your trusted captain, Roger, is here to navigate through the tempestuous tale posted by a brave dad on Reddit. Our protagonist today wonders, ‘Am I the Asshole (AITA) for telling my kids, ‘Mom said no?’ We’ve got toddlers, tantrums, and a touch of marital tension. Let’s get into it!

Keeping the Parental United Front: The Golden Rule of Parenting

First, a big shout-out to the courageous dad who ventured into the wild, wild west of Reddit to bare his soul. Our hero has two adorable little rascals—aged 2 and 4—each equipped with the cunning and guile worthy of a pint-sized Machiavelli. And what does every modern-day Machiavelli do when they hear a ‘no’? Well, they pull off a diplomatic maneuver straight out of Sun Tzu’s ‘The Art of War’ and go ask the other parent.

Our Dad-in-Distress firmly believes in the iron law of parenting: if one parent says no, the other backs them up. He’s got 99 problems, but inconsistency ain’t one. In theory, this practice breeds a cohesive front, thwarting any toddler uprising. The plan was foolproof—until it wasn’t.

The Morning Rumble: Toddlers vs. The Parental Authority

The scene is set: It’s morning. Coffee—possibly cold—sits abandoned on the counter. Breakfast chaos reigns. The 4-year-old, let’s call her Mini-Machiavelli, asks Mom if she can play a game that always turns the living room into a disaster zone. Mom, being a champion of cleanliness and sanity, says, ‘No.’ Clearly, this wasn’t Mini-Machiavelli’s first rodeo because she immediately turned to Dad with doe eyes and a hopeful smile.

The Twist: The Double-Edged ‘No’

Now, Dad’s internal monologue goes something like this: ‘Ah, no, sweet child of mine. I won’t be bamboozled today!’ And, sticking to the script, he channels his inner warrior and says, ‘No, your mom told you no.’

Here’s where the plot thickens. Mom is suddenly upset. And Dad is left flabbergasted, scratching his head wondering why he’s landed in the doghouse for what seemed like a textbook response. So now here we are, gripping the edge of our seats, as Dad turns to Reddit for answers.

The Reddit Roulade: Keyboard Warriors Weigh In

When you toss a conundrum like this into the vast seas of Reddit, you’re bound to get a mixed bag of wisdom, wit, and pure comedic gold. Some armchair parenting experts chimed in with solid advice, while others, well, let’s just say their user names should’ve been a clue to their level of expertise.

The consensus, however, leaned towards Dad not being TA. In fact, many applauded his consistency, suggesting that the issue might not be with the philosophy but rather with how it was communicated. Did Dad inadvertently make Mom the bad cop? Did the framing of ‘Mom said no’ undermine her authority rather than support it? Ah, the minefield of marital dynamics!

Roger’s Razor-Sharp Take: Being the Parental Diplomat

Now, it’s time for Roger’s two cents, free of charge. First off, Dad, props to you for sticking to your guns. You’re trying to keep the parental fortress strong and indomitable, and that’s commendable. But here’s a little nugget of wisdom from your friendly neighborhood writer: communication isn’t just about what we say but how we say it.

Instead of flinging the ‘Mom said no’ grenade, you could try a more collaborative approach. Something like, ‘We agree that it’s not a good time for that game right now.’ This way, it’s a united parental decision without throwing Mom under the proverbial bus.

Remember, kids are like little emotional sponges. They pick up on everything. If they sense even the tiniest crack in the parental armor, they’ll exploit it. Because God forbid they have to wait 30 minutes to play ‘Messy Madness’ or whatever catastrophe-inducing game they’re obsessed with.

The Final Verdict: TA or Angelic Ally?

So, to answer your burning question: No, dear Dad, you’re not the asshole. If anything, you’re a well-meaning, law-abiding citizen of Parentland. But even the best-intentioned parents can step on the occasional marital landmine.

The next time the kids try to play one parent against the other, just remember—it’s less about the ‘no’ and more about ensuring that ‘no’ feels like a team effort. You’re not the bad cop or the good cop. You’re both just… well, cops. Just ones who need a nap and a long, uninterrupted shower.

Conclusion: The Takeaway

Parenting is a battlefield. Sometimes you win, sometimes the kids build a fort in the living room out of your freshly folded laundry. But as long as you and your partner are united, you’re ahead of the game. So, buckle up, hold your partner’s hand, and march into the fray together. As for the rest of you reading this, treat yourselves to a glass of wine or a cup of tea and thank your lucky stars it wasn’t your mess to clean up today.

Original story

I have two kids, who are 2 and 4 years old. And one thing I try to reinforce with them is that if mom or dad says “no” if they go to the other parent, the answer they will get is no.

Which means if they ask my wife, and she says no, regardless of how I feel on the matter, I’m going to back her up. And I expect my wife to do the same.

Well this morning we were getting ready to leave and 4 year old asked my wife if she could get out a game that always makes a mess. So my wife said no, immediately 4 turned to me and asked the same question.

So I said, “No, your mom told you no.” Which upset my wife, and I don’t quite understand why.

AITA?